by Dvivid » Tue Jul 03, 2012 11:20 am
Ba Duan Jin have existed for over 1,000 and they were passed down in an oral tradition in the form of poems. Of course, passing from one person to the next has resulted in many many variations of the forms. And some modernizations are actually improvements. But reading those original poems, which fortunately are preserved, gives us a clue about the intention of the exercise, and therefore correct posture. I share this only to be helpful.
#1:
“Double hands hold up the heavens to regulate the Sanjiao, the triple-burner.
Sanjiao passes qi freely and smoothly, illnesses disappear.
Reverse hands to face the sky and raise both arms.
Straighten your chest, straighten your waist and swing to both sides.
Stand upright and be steady.
Practice long, the body becomes strong, and you will feel happy.”
Its true, this one says nothing about lifting the heels. But the sanyinjiao is linked not only to the hands, but the feet as well. I think this one could go either way, but there is more benefit to lifting the heels, physically, mentally, and energetically, so why not?
#2:
“Left and right bend the bow, like shooting a hawk,
two arms strong and firm to strengthen kidneys and waist.
Bend the elbow horizontal to the shoulder, your mind trying hard to pull.
Hand arrow aims at the target. Use the eyes to stare.
Left and right shoot for twenty-four.
Ride the horse and squat down to increase efficiency.”
Hand arrow aims at the target. Use the eyes to stare. This movement teaches us to use the YI (intention) to lead the QI (energy) by focusing on the target, which is a point outside of the body, thus leading Qi through the meridians to open your circulation, and exchange Qi with your surroundings. Locking the wrist I think is not correct for that one. That traps energy at your wrist, and basically makes it into a hard-style qigong exercise.
It is natural that forms will evolve when passed from person to person for 1,000 years!
Its like saying a sentence to someone, like "I don't like feeling woozy" and then they pass it on through 1000 people, and it ends up being "the dolphin is in the jacuzzi."
"Avoid Prejudice, Be Objective in Your Judgement, Be Scientific, Be Logical and Make Sense, Do Not Ignore Prior Experience." - Dr. Yang
http://www.ymaa.com/publishing