by shuharicrane » Mon Jul 18, 2005 10:47 pm
I have been training taiji for nearly four years now, an amount of time that amounts to only a drop in the bucket. But I have 14 years of training experience in Karate, which although is a relatively small amount of time to some, is ultimately over half of my life.
I agree with No.6, loseness, relaxation, softness, "Song", or however you choose to define it, is not a concept that is owned or exclusive to the so called internal arts. Sure it is something that internal arts are specifically good at demonstrating, but there are things that every art exemplifies well, and things that those same arts do not well exemplify. Which is why it is important to cross train in the first place, so that as warriors, teachers and human beings, we are more complete, physically, mentally, and spiritually.
Furthermore, in the region in which I train, the reverse is true. Here it seems that those who have only Taiji training are more stiff than those who have had training in Karate (or in other arts). Here it is difficult to find a quality Taiji instructor. In other places, I'm sure it is difficult to find a quality Karate instructor, making the competency of relaxation in students who cross train the two arts lessened.
If I have a student that happens to have brown hair and is not demonstrating a particular technique up to par, then I tell that student. What I do not do is go out and find every brown haired individual that trains the same art as myself and try to become their instructor. Frankly, my time could be better spent in the classroom with my students. The old maxim holds true, "Don't judge a book by its cover."